Lothair and Louis V: The End of the Carolingians (954–987) · EARLY MIDDLE AGES
After 978, Lothair emerges with greater prestige, but the war has highlighted a political fact: Hugh Capet is indispensable. The decade therefore opens on an unstable balance between Carolingian king and Robertian prince.
In 979, Lothair associates his son Louis with kingship and has him anointed. The goal is to secure transmission and prevent a vacancy from turning the crown into an “election” controlled by the great men.
In July 980, Lothair meets Otto II at Margut‑sur‑Chiers, on the border. The agreement is détente: Lothair renounces ambitions over Lotharingia, allowing the emperor to focus on Italy. Diplomacy places western kingship back in an Ottonian orbit, carried by influential Lotharingian bishops.
The understanding is badly perceived by the Robertians, kept out of negotiations. At the same time, Hugh Capet strengthens his power (for example by seizing Montreuil). Fearing being cornered, he seeks his own supports, going as far as Rome in 981 to contact the emperor. At court, the idea of arresting the Robertian on his return shows how fragile trust is.
To counter the kingdom’s “second”, the crown attempts a shift of gravity: Lothair marries his heir to a great lady of the Midi to restore royal presence south of the Loire. The project fails quickly, but it reveals the strategy: broaden the royal base so as not to depend on a single prince.